Beyond the Border: Assessing the U.S. Strategy for Central America and the Challenges Ahead

Commentary & Analysis

Source: Peacekeeper Insight

Commentary: In the heart of Central America, a region riddled with poverty, violence, and climate vulnerability, the stakes are high—and so is the need for a sustainable solution. Migration flows from countries like Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador have been a defining issue for the United States and a persistent challenge for each administration. With the 2021 "U.S. Strategy for Addressing the Root Causes of Migration in Central America," the Biden administration presented a bold, comprehensive plan aimed not just at treating the symptoms of migration but at tackling its very roots. Yet as with all ambitious policies, success is uncertain, and risks loom large.

The question now is whether the U.S. can craft a policy that genuinely addresses the complexities of migration, rooted in decades of political instability, economic despair, and environmental degradation. How effective is the current strategy in dealing with these issues? And what more is needed to make this a turning point for Central America and U.S. relations with the region?

Source: Peacekeeper Insight

Understanding the Root Causes: Economics, Violence, and Climate Pressures

Migration from Central America isn’t a simple, spur-of-the-moment decision. It’s a choice driven by desperation—a response to persistent conditions that make staying unbearable. The Biden administration’s strategy zeroes in on five major “root causes” of migration, namely economic inequality, poor governance, human rights abuses, high levels of violence, and the acute impacts of climate change​. But addressing these root causes is no easy task, particularly in a region where years of underinvestment, corruption, and vulnerability to climate impacts have compounded the hardships for millions.

Economic Insecurity and Inequality

Economically, Central America is among the poorest regions in the Western Hemisphere. The Biden administration’s strategy seeks to drive job creation through private sector expansion, having already helped generate over 250,000 employment opportunities. Additionally, significant investments have been directed toward education, targeting young people in particular, to help equip them with literacy and vocational skills to enter the workforce​.

Despite these efforts, the obstacles to sustainable economic growth in Central America are formidable. High inflation, limited job opportunities, and entrenched inequalities create a cycle of economic dependency and instability, which aid alone cannot resolve. While the strategy’s focus on economic opportunity is crucial, it must overcome deep-rooted economic stagnation, fueled by both domestic policies and international forces. Without structural reforms to promote stable and inclusive growth, economic aid risks becoming a short-term fix in a situation demanding long-term solutions.

Source: Peacekeeper Insight

Corruption and Governance: The Core Challenge

Corruption remains a fundamental issue that U.S. aid cannot directly solve but must address to be effective. In Honduras, Guatemala, and El Salvador, corruption siphons resources meant for public services, perpetuating cycles of poverty and mistrust. In response, the U.S. strategy has incorporated training programs and resources for anti-corruption efforts, aimed at strengthening the rule of law and improving accountability within these governments. Thousands of government officials and non-governmental actors have been trained to uphold ethical standards​.

However, corruption isn’t just a barrier to development; it’s a barrier to genuine reform. While training programs and diplomatic pressure are steps in the right direction, Central America’s deeply rooted political and economic systems make anti-corruption efforts an uphill battle. Without persistent political will from Central American governments, corruption will continue to erode the effectiveness of U.S.-backed programs. Indeed, the U.S. may find that success in Central America requires more than just good intentions; it needs enduring partnerships with leaders who share a vision of transparency and reform—a tall order in countries where public trust in government is often tenuous.

Rising Risks: Climate Change and Its Human Impact

Central America is one of the most climate-vulnerable regions globally, with hurricanes, droughts, and erratic weather patterns driving people away from their homes. Farmers, who rely on increasingly unpredictable seasons, face devastating crop losses that push them further into poverty and fuel migration. In response, the U.S. strategy has funneled resources into climate-resilient agriculture and infrastructure projects, aiming to shield communities from the worst impacts of climate change​.

While these initiatives are essential, they face a fundamental problem: adaptation is slow, and climate impacts are accelerating. Climate-related displacement is expected to surge in the coming years, as weather events and resource shortages become more severe. To be effective, climate resilience efforts must not only address current vulnerabilities but anticipate the future needs of communities increasingly at risk. U.S. policy in the region will need to shift toward a more flexible, forward-looking model if it is to create lasting resilience.

Assessing U.S. Border Policy: Deterrence vs. Sustainable Solutions

The root causes strategy works in tandem with heightened border measures, such as the new asylum restrictions announced in 2024. These restrictions aim to reduce irregular migration by disqualifying individuals crossing illegally from asylum eligibility, a move that has already resulted in a 55% decrease in migrant encounters at the southern border​.

But while the deterrence aspect of border policy has shown initial effectiveness, it comes with risks. Migration flows don’t stop; they adapt. The dangers of forcing migrants to choose alternative, often more perilous routes cannot be ignored. Without a viable, stable environment at home, migrants will continue to seek refuge elsewhere, often risking their lives in the process. This is a complex reality that border measures alone cannot resolve. Border policy may curb migration in the short term, but it must be complemented by policies that address the regional issues driving migration if it is to offer a meaningful solution.

Regional Partnerships and the Role of International Cooperation

The Biden administration’s strategy is notable for its emphasis on international cooperation, enlisting support from allies like Mexico and Japan to bolster Central America’s development efforts. These partnerships demonstrate an understanding that migration is a hemispheric issue, with cross-border implications that no one country can address alone. Collaboration with Central American governments, however, remains a challenge, as each country’s internal politics and priorities differ, complicating coordinated efforts​.

Moreover, a sustainable partnership model requires that Central American countries take ownership of their progress. U.S. policy cannot succeed if it merely fosters dependency, providing resources without securing a genuine commitment to reform. For meaningful progress, Central American governments must invest in their own capacity to implement and sustain programs. The U.S. may catalyze development, but the heavy lifting must come from within.

A Delicate Balancing Act: Challenges and Implications Ahead

The U.S. Strategy for Central America is an ambitious step forward, yet it faces daunting challenges. From corruption to climate change, the factors driving migration are deep-seated and interwoven, making them resistant to easy fixes. Economic dependency on U.S. aid, for instance, remains a potential risk. Aid may stimulate short-term gains, but without accompanying policy changes in Central America, it cannot sustain long-term growth. Dependency erodes resilience, and Central America’s future hinges on the region’s capacity to build its own foundation for economic stability.

Further, rising migration pressures may escalate political tensions in the United States, adding urgency to the search for effective solutions. As the 2024 election approaches, immigration will likely remain a polarizing issue, with public sentiment often favoring stricter border controls over complex, long-term strategies. Navigating these domestic pressures while pursuing a humanitarian approach requires a deft balancing act. U.S. leaders must convince an often-skeptical public that investment in Central America’s stability is not only a moral imperative but also a strategic one.

Moving from Aid to Agency

The U.S. approach to Central America reflects an important shift, moving away from reactive border enforcement and toward a proactive, comprehensive strategy that targets migration’s root causes. By addressing economic insecurity, governance challenges, human rights issues, violence, and climate risks, this policy represents a holistic attempt to stabilize the region and curb migration pressures over the long term.

However, the success of this strategy hinges on its capacity to foster genuine agency within Central America. The U.S. must encourage Central American leaders to assume responsibility for their own reform agendas, embracing policies that prioritize their citizens’ well-being over political expediency. Likewise, international partners must commit to sustained, aligned efforts that reinforce rather than replace local capacities.

Ultimately, the U.S. Strategy for Central America is an experiment in comprehensive intervention, a reflection of both ambition and empathy. It’s a policy that aims not just to stem the tide of migration but to offer Central Americans a viable future within their homelands. Achieving this vision will require more than just policy shifts; it demands enduring partnerships, a commitment to adaptive strategies, and a belief that lasting change is possible. For the U.S. and Central America alike, the road ahead is fraught with challenges, but it may also be the pathway to a more stable, equitable region.

---

Analytic Report: 2024 U.S. Strategy on Central American Migration and Foreign Policy Response

Review of CRS report Central American Migration and U.S. Policy Response

To access the full risk assessment report consider upgrading to a premium subscription